• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Reviews from Broadway and Beyond

  • Now Playing
  • Recently Opened
    • Broadway
    • Off-Broadway
    • Beyond
  • Critics’ Picks
  • Our Critics
    • About Us
    • Melissa Rose Bernardo
    • Michael Feingold
    • David Finkle
    • Elysa Gardner
    • Jesse Oxfeld
    • MICHAEL SOMMERS
    • Steven Suskin
    • Frank Scheck
    • Roma Torre
    • Bob Verini
  • Sign Up
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Now Playing
  • Recently Opened
    • Broadway
    • Off-Broadway
    • Beyond
  • Critics’ Picks
  • Our Critics
    • About Us
    • Melissa Rose Bernardo
    • Michael Feingold
    • David Finkle
    • Elysa Gardner
    • Jesse Oxfeld
    • MICHAEL SOMMERS
    • Steven Suskin
    • Frank Scheck
    • Roma Torre
    • Bob Verini
  • Sign Up
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
April 3, 2019 7:30 pm

I Carry Your Heart: A Play About a Transplant And What Else Is Planted

By David Finkle

★★★★☆ Georgette Kelly keenly sees how many hearts are affected after one meaningful operation

Dey Young and Dana Scurlock in I Carry Your Heart. Photo: Sehee Kim

Most likely the first (and perhaps only) question anyone asks when hearing about a transplant—heart or other organ—is about the resulting acceptance or rejection. Certainly, that’s what Georgette Kelly concerns herself with in I Carry Your Heart, but her considerations go much further in ways that may seem obvious as her play unfolds but are truly fresh and powerful.

Kelly wants to know how after a transplant has taken place it affects the donor and the recipient and even, more broadly, how it can impinge profoundly on the donor’s family and the recipient’s family in ways that can manifest as highly complex—as (excuse the pun) heart-rending.

Tess (Dana Scurlock) has a failing heart. So when the hospital call comes that a healthy heart is suddenly available, her wife Lydia (Nicole Paloma Sarro) rushes her to the hospital, leaving her and Tess’ stepson Josh (John Anthony Torres) hoping for the best. Waiting for the outcome, Lydia berates herself for hurrying so determinedly that she allowed Tess no time to pray before leaving home. Josh, worried himself, assures his mother she did exactly what she had to do.

In the meantime, Phoebe Wilder (Rebi Paganini), the estranged daughter of the donor, has also arrived at the hospital, having only just learned of her mother’s bequest and trying to ascertain that it’s all on the up-and-up. She wants to be assured her mother’s organs haven’t been prematurely harvested. Eager to find out what she can, she grills intensive-care-unit doctor Blake (Nico Piccardo) until she realizes she’s been rude and makes amends that lead to an incipient romance.

All the while, donor Debra Wilder (Dey Young), a successful novelist, wanders through the properly antiseptic set. (Justin Swader and Christopher Swader are the designers; Emily White chose the beige peignoir Debra floats in.) Debra is living on, of course, alive in the imaginations of Phoebe and Tess. The point is that once we’re deceased, we remain present in ways such as a heart beating in another body and, more traditionally of course, in persistent memory.

In the specific I Carry Your Heart case, Debra exists even more decidedly having left behind a memoir for daughter Phoebe. It’s intended to be an apology for what’s gone on between them over the silent years—Debra’s having been a successful novelist and perhaps careless mother to Phoebe, Phoebe’s being a budding poet chafing in her mother’s shadow.

And that’s only a fraction of what results from a transplant that goes well at first but has its worrying complications. In other very credible developments, Tess thinks about wanting to thank Debra’s family—whoever they may be—and sends a letter without advising Lydia. Phoebe falls for Blake and he for her, but her difficulty in overcoming the emotional distance she’s created as her mother’s daughter gets in the way.

The psychological problems explored here are personal, unique. (Developing psychological problems are likely never discussed when surgeons describe the impending operation.) But they emphasize the unexpected repercussions that can eventuate when something serious but at the same time matter-of-fact transpires. With I Carry Your Heart, a family consisting of two women and a teenage boy and a family that’s been reduced to only a single survivor must deal with outcomes that might never have been contemplated in the initial urgent circumstances.

At the very least, they’re awkward, “awkward” an adjective that crops up in the dialogue. Curiously, some of the writing comes across as awkward, at least as directed by Cate Caplin and played by an otherwise accomplished cast taking on especially delicate, not often tackled material.

But there might be something else going on here. I Carry Your Heart (the title is lifted from the e. e. cummings poem) is presented in 59E59 Theatre’s smallest space. The actors asked to present these fragile matters are almost constantly smack up against the three rows of patrons. Is it as awkward for them as it is for the audience? If so, it may be that I Carry Your Heart is a drama that requires a proscenium stage to have its strongest impact.

There’s no gainsaying that playwright Kelly has located a subject just waiting to be examined. She’s brought it valuable attention after years, maybe decades or more, when no such thing as bedside manner courses were available. That’s long since changed for the better, but perhaps what’s needed now (if there aren’t any) are specialty courses—advising, for instance, on potential transplant ramifications.

Thanks to Georgette Kelly, for, among other things, dispensing one important bedside lesson.

I Carry Your Heart opened April 3, 2019, at 59E59 and runs through April 20. Tickets and information: 59e59.org

About David Finkle

David Finkle is a freelance journalist specializing in the arts and politics. He has reviewed theater for several decades, for publications including The Village Voice and Theatermania.com, where for 12 years he was chief drama critic. He is also currently chief drama critic at The Clyde Fitch Report. For an archive of older reviews, go here. Email: david@nystagereview.com.

Primary Sidebar

Blue Man Group A New Holiday Surprise: Ho-Ho-Hum, and a Lot of Fun

By Roma Torre

★★★☆☆ The famed troupe returns to New York with a holiday hue but still the same old blue.

The Good Thief: Boastful Self-Incriminating Hero(?) Is More Than Good

By David Finkle

★★★★☆ Christopher Fitzgerald has high old time with Conor McPherson's happy hit man, Justin Waldman directing

Slanted Floors: Living Room Theater, Literally

By Frank Scheck

★★★☆☆ Adam Chanler-Berat and Kyle Beltran star in Billy McEntee's play performed for an audience of thirty in a one-bedroom apartment.

The Fantasticks: Fresh but Still Familiar

By Melissa Rose Bernardo

★★★★☆ The longest-running musical in history makes its Broadway debut with a new boy-meets-boy story

CRITICS' PICKS

Downstate: The Disturbing Humanity of the Inhuman

★★★★★ Bruce Norris's unsettling drama returns to New York in a captivating Broadway production directed by Joe Mantello

Here There Are Blueberries: Riveting Documentary Theater

★★★★★ Moisés Kaufman and Amanda Gronich's riveting play revolves around a donation of troubling Nazi photographs to the U.S. Holocaust Musuem.

We'll See

We’ll See: Sitting Down to Dinner, Once Again, With Our Beloved Apple Family

★★★★★ Our contemporary Chekhov, Richard Nelson, returns with another up-to-the-minute Rhinebeck-set drama

The company of The Heart. Photo: Joan Marcus

The Heart: A Bold New Musical Chronicles a Life-or-Death Story

★★★★☆ Electronic music drives an exceptional musical about a major medical procedure

Imaginary Invalid

The Imaginary Invalid: Just What the Doctor Ordered

★★★★☆ Molière’s final play gets a lively, luxe-looking 90-minute adaptation by its star, Tony winner Bill Irwin

860: Billy Crystal Brings Down the House

★★★★★ Crystal is at his comedic best proving a lifetime of memories are fireproof.

Sign up for new reviews

Copyright © 2026 • New York Stage Review • All Rights Reserved.

Website Built by Digital Culture NYC.