• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Reviews from Broadway and Beyond

  • Now Playing
  • Recently Opened
    • Broadway
    • Off-Broadway
    • Beyond
  • Critics’ Picks
  • Our Critics
    • About Us
    • Melissa Rose Bernardo
    • Michael Feingold
    • David Finkle
    • Elysa Gardner
    • Jesse Oxfeld
    • MICHAEL SOMMERS
    • Steven Suskin
    • Frank Scheck
    • Roma Torre
    • Bob Verini
  • Sign Up
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Now Playing
  • Recently Opened
    • Broadway
    • Off-Broadway
    • Beyond
  • Critics’ Picks
  • Our Critics
    • About Us
    • Melissa Rose Bernardo
    • Michael Feingold
    • David Finkle
    • Elysa Gardner
    • Jesse Oxfeld
    • MICHAEL SOMMERS
    • Steven Suskin
    • Frank Scheck
    • Roma Torre
    • Bob Verini
  • Sign Up
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
March 5, 2019 9:56 pm

The Cake: When the Antigay Baker Meets a Same-Sex Couple

By Jesse Oxfeld

★★★★☆ Debra Jo Rupp is the key ingredient in Bekah Brunstetter's sympathetic portrait of cultures colliding

Debra Jo Rupp in The Cake. Photo: Joan Marcus
Debra Jo Rupp in The Cake. Photo: Joan Marcus

There’s a question left mostly unaddressed in the debates over gay rights and so-called religious freedom laws. Of course discrimination should be illegal, but why would anyone want a same-sex wedding cake made by a bigoted, antigay baker?

In The Cake, which opened tonight at the Manhattan Theatre Club’s off-Broadway space in City Center, playwright Bekah Brunstetter has found the circumstance: You’ll want an antigay baker to make your same-sex wedding cake when the cake guru in your North Carolina hometown is your dead mom’s best friend—and also a conservative Christian.

To Brunstetter’s great credit, that setup as revealed in her intriguing, timely play feels natural, not contrived. The Cake, which initially seems a goofy confection—and stars the inimitable Debra Jo Rupp, who specializes in ingenuously self-serious goofballs—turns out to be a thoughtful examination of changing cultural mores in which all sides have only the best intentions, even if they never quite see eye to eye.

[Read Steven Suskin’s ★★★ review here.]

We meet Rupp’s Della first, in her eponymous cake shop, carefully icing her latest creation. She’s in a reverie, speaking of the importance of following a recipe precisely. It’s the key, she says, to making a great cake—and, we’ll soon enough learn, a metaphor for her view on life, in which there are precise rules for what should and should not be done. It’s a striking moment as directed by Lynne Meadow, a glowing Wayne Thiebaud tableau vivant that treats the cakes as virtual fetish objects. (John Lee Beatty has designed the sets.)

Then set pieces revolve and we’re in Della’s full establishment, a homey neighborhood bakery. She’s talking to a pleasant African-American woman (Marinda Anderson), Macy, who appears to be taking notes. It’s unclear whether this is an interview, a confessional, or just some idle chatter. It turns out it’s the last, and what we soon discover—but Della doesn’t—is that Macy and her bride-to-be, Jen (Genevieve Angelson), are in town to plan their wedding. Soon enough, Macy outs Jen—nee Jenny, in her younger days—to Della, who reacts with shock. Della, you see, sees Jen/Jenny as a surrogate daughter, but she also believes marriage is between a man and a woman. “I would love more than anything, truly anything in this world, to make your cake,” Della eventually tells Jen. “But I just — I can’t support — what you’re doing.”

Brunstetter has fun in her script. Della is set to compete on The Great American Baking Show, and there are dream-sequence moments in which Della’s anxiety manifests as fantasy (and fantastical) exchanges with the Baking Show judge. Rupp brings charm, daffiness, and heart to her character. And it’s refreshing to see a culture-war depiction that presents all its combatants as good-hearted and struggling. As much as Della is heartbroken by feeling she must condemn Jen, Jen is guilt-ridden about upsetting Della’s well-ordered world.

Ultimately, it turns out that Della’s world is less well-ordered than one might think. She and her goofusy but religiously domineering husband, Tim (Dan Daily), are in an affection but sexless marriage, and Della is frustrated. She wants more from life, both romantically and intellectually, and Jen is making her reassess her views, slightly.

In fact, Della can sometime feel a bit like Laura Bush in Curtis Sittenfeld’s novel American Wife — it’s a bit too convenient, perhaps, that a closet progressive is always lurking within a sympathetic conservative. Still, Rupp’s good nature makes the character work.

Macy, the interloping bride-to-be, is a tougher character to get a fix on, both devoted to Jen and also, sometimes, inexplicably unfeeling toward her plight. She’s also sometimes presented as the product of a progressive, tolerant world — “your Mom is a therapist,” Jen tells her. “She buys you weed. Your parents were never even married” — and elsewhere as someone whose father threw a Bible at her head when she came out and now doesn’t speak to her. Jen seems too passive, constantly put upon.

But even with its flaws, this play works, on the strength of its sympathetic takes and Brunstetter’s sharp script. The Cake, as it turns out, is sweet.

The Cake opened March 5, 2019, at City Center Stage I and runs through March 31. Tickets and information: manhattantheatreclub.com

About Jesse Oxfeld

Jesse Oxfeld was the theater critic of The New York Observer from 2009 to 2014. He has also written about theater for Entertainment Weekly, New York magazine, The New York Times Book Review, The Forward, The Times of London, and other publications. Twitter: @joxfeld. Email: jesse@nystagereview.com.

Primary Sidebar

Elektra: Grade-A Director Daniel Fish Has His Creative Way With Sophokles

By David Finkle

★★★★☆ Tina Benko is the vengeful protagonist in Nobelist Anne Carson's translation for today's political climate

Now You See Me Live: It’s Magic

By Michael Sommers

★★★☆☆ Five experts in illusion mingle with their audience for a holiday show

Much Ado About Nothing: No-Fear Shakespeare, Set to a Synth-Pop Beat

By Melissa Rose Bernardo

★★★★★ Jamie Lloyd directs a bubblegum-pink production of the Bard’s giddiest romantic comedy

Much Ado About Nothing: Party Like It’s 1599

By Frank Scheck

★★★★☆ Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell star in Jamie Lloyd's raucous, music and dance-filled production of Shakespeare's comedy.

CRITICS' PICKS

Downstate: The Disturbing Humanity of the Inhuman

★★★★★ Bruce Norris's unsettling drama returns to New York in a captivating Broadway production directed by Joe Mantello

Here There Are Blueberries: Riveting Documentary Theater

★★★★★ Moisés Kaufman and Amanda Gronich's riveting play revolves around a donation of troubling Nazi photographs to the U.S. Holocaust Musuem.

We'll See

We’ll See: Sitting Down to Dinner, Once Again, With Our Beloved Apple Family

★★★★★ Our contemporary Chekhov, Richard Nelson, returns with another up-to-the-minute Rhinebeck-set drama

The company of The Heart. Photo: Joan Marcus

The Heart: A Bold New Musical Chronicles a Life-or-Death Story

★★★★☆ Electronic music drives an exceptional musical about a major medical procedure

Imaginary Invalid

The Imaginary Invalid: Just What the Doctor Ordered

★★★★☆ Molière’s final play gets a lively, luxe-looking 90-minute adaptation by its star, Tony winner Bill Irwin

860: Billy Crystal Brings Down the House

★★★★★ Crystal is at his comedic best proving a lifetime of memories are fireproof.

Sign up for new reviews

Copyright © 2026 • New York Stage Review • All Rights Reserved.

Website Built by Digital Culture NYC.