• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Reviews from Broadway and Beyond

  • Now Playing
  • Recently Opened
    • Broadway
    • Off-Broadway
    • Beyond
  • Critics’ Picks
  • Our Critics
    • About Us
    • Melissa Rose Bernardo
    • Michael Feingold
    • David Finkle
    • Elysa Gardner
    • Jesse Oxfeld
    • MICHAEL SOMMERS
    • Steven Suskin
    • Frank Scheck
    • Roma Torre
    • Bob Verini
  • Sign Up
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Now Playing
  • Recently Opened
    • Broadway
    • Off-Broadway
    • Beyond
  • Critics’ Picks
  • Our Critics
    • About Us
    • Melissa Rose Bernardo
    • Michael Feingold
    • David Finkle
    • Elysa Gardner
    • Jesse Oxfeld
    • MICHAEL SOMMERS
    • Steven Suskin
    • Frank Scheck
    • Roma Torre
    • Bob Verini
  • Sign Up
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
November 20, 2025 9:59 pm

Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York): A Tasty Slice of Cake

By David Finkle

★★★★☆ Musical import tells sweet-bitter tale of Brit and American finding each other and themselves

Sam Tutty, Christiani Pitts in Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York). Photo: Matthew Murphy

Robin Rainey (Christiani Pitts) and Dougal Todd (Sam Tutty) meet cute in Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York), with book and score by Jim Barne and Kit Buchan, and Tim Jackson as director/choreographer.

Furiously cheerful Dougal has just arrived in New York for the first time to attend the wedding of his 57-year-old father Mark, a man he’s never met. As the sister of 30-year-old bride Melissa, Robin has been assigned to collect Dougal at the airport but is determined to complete the task of seeing the short-of-money fellow to what turns out to be a Canal Street fleabag where she can leave him to his own devices.

So there they are, two strangers, one determined to see as many sights as he can, meet his father at the next-day nuptials before heading home the following day; the other to go about pre-wedding assignments while taking time off from the coffee-shop job she hates because she’s in her late twenties and has no better prospects.

[Read Frank Scheck’s ★★★★☆ review here.]

Their current situations mean in musical-comedy terms that both Dougal and Robin immediately get to sing format-traditional I-want songs.  Dougal, who’s already delivered a sensational arrival number, “New York,” intones the sensitive “Dad” about his uncertainty confronting the man who deserted his mother and him many years earlier. Robin storms angrily through “What’ll It Be,” her daily on-the-job query to customers and her own question to herself about her future.

With the back-to-back tunes, bookwriters-songsmiths Barne and Buchan have established what theater people often refer to as the “the journey” on which the focal characters are about to travel.  Dougal and Rainey much more literally carry on their own journey.

It’s not just to visit the Statue of Liberty and other must-see New York City landmarks. They don’t get to many of those. They trudge more pointedly towards confronting each other and, more significantly, themselves. Robin only slowly realizes as the two of them carry the wedding cake from Brooklyn to its destination that he isn’t entirely a human ball-and-chain.

On the trek, Dougal realizes he must confront the uncertainties he’s masked with his naturally carefree manner. He discovers he can’t dismiss his darker aspects. The change for both intensifies after a boozy shopping spree pursued with Mark’s credit card, which is not meant to be used that way.

In other words, the musical isn’t entirely a happy-go-lucky romp. Ultimately and seriously, Two Strangers is written to demonstrate that problems, such as long-held secrets coming to light, can often be solved when two people attack them together. As such, the production—first seen in 2023 at North London’s fringe Kiln Theatre with subsequent stops in the West End and at Cambridge’s American Repertory Theatre—sneaks into town as an adroitly-wrought and probing winner.

Beginning with Dougal’s explosive “New York,” the score is notable for several sometimes cute, sometimes pungent numbers. There’s an amusing duet “Under the Mistletoe,” surely appropriate this Yuletide season. There’s Dougal’s worried “About to Go In,” where he’s outside the church and suddenly reluctant to attend the ceremony. There’s Robin’s potent “He Doesn’t Exist,” the impetus for which won’t be revealed here as spoiler prone as well as her “This Year,” about continually living a disillusioned life. (Ted Arthur hotly conducts the five-member band perched on a balcony high above the players.)

Speaking of the stage look: the always clever Soutra Gilmour has placed two groups of different-sized metal valises one on top of the other, some of them eventually opening to disclose a closet or a cabinet or whatever, to represent luggage piling up at the carousel where Dougal claims his valise. For the rest of the musical, the luggage heaps become a New York City skyscape the actors can circulate and climb. Here’s an installation on which lighting designer Jack Knowles can illuminate colorful neon strips. Ingenious? You bet.

Then there’s the acting, singing and brief dancing. Pitts’s performance, especially svelte and stylish in Gilmour’s night-at-the-Plaza gown, is mercurial throughout, making Robin’s initial annoyance and then intelligent concern thoroughly penetrating.

As to newcomer Tutty, who took home last year’s Olivier Award for Best Actor in a Musical for his take on the imported Dear Evan Hansen: His “New York” introduction makes it dazzlingly clear that a London musical leading-man hasn’t been carried in on the local theater tide since Tommy Steele in Half a Sixpence and Anthony Newley in The Roar of the Greasepaint-The Smell of the Crowd. Tutty’s appealing looks, pure voice, comic instincts, and obvious acting skills, and somehow resemblance to a living Teletubby make him the huge plus for a vital Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) run.

Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) opened November 20, 2025 at the Longacre Theatre. Tickets and information: twostrangersmusical.com

About David Finkle

David Finkle is a freelance journalist specializing in the arts and politics. He has reviewed theater for several decades, for publications including The Village Voice and Theatermania.com, where for 12 years he was chief drama critic. He is also currently chief drama critic at The Clyde Fitch Report. For an archive of older reviews, go here. Email: david@nystagereview.com.

Primary Sidebar

Much Ado About Nothing: No-Fear Shakespeare, Set to a Synth-Pop Beat

By Melissa Rose Bernardo

★★★★★ Jamie Lloyd directs a bubblegum-pink production of the Bard’s giddiest romantic comedy

Much Ado About Nothing: Party Like It’s 1599

By Frank Scheck

★★★★☆ Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell star in Jamie Lloyd's raucous, music and dance-filled production of Shakespeare's comedy.

Blue Man Group A New Holiday Surprise: Ho-Ho-Hum, and a Lot of Fun

By Roma Torre

★★★☆☆ The famed troupe returns to New York with a holiday hue but still the same old blue.

The Good Thief: Boastful Self-Incriminating Hero(?) Is More Than Good

By David Finkle

★★★★☆ Christopher Fitzgerald has high old time with Conor McPherson's happy hit man, Justin Waldman directing

CRITICS' PICKS

Downstate: The Disturbing Humanity of the Inhuman

★★★★★ Bruce Norris's unsettling drama returns to New York in a captivating Broadway production directed by Joe Mantello

Here There Are Blueberries: Riveting Documentary Theater

★★★★★ Moisés Kaufman and Amanda Gronich's riveting play revolves around a donation of troubling Nazi photographs to the U.S. Holocaust Musuem.

We'll See

We’ll See: Sitting Down to Dinner, Once Again, With Our Beloved Apple Family

★★★★★ Our contemporary Chekhov, Richard Nelson, returns with another up-to-the-minute Rhinebeck-set drama

The company of The Heart. Photo: Joan Marcus

The Heart: A Bold New Musical Chronicles a Life-or-Death Story

★★★★☆ Electronic music drives an exceptional musical about a major medical procedure

Imaginary Invalid

The Imaginary Invalid: Just What the Doctor Ordered

★★★★☆ Molière’s final play gets a lively, luxe-looking 90-minute adaptation by its star, Tony winner Bill Irwin

860: Billy Crystal Brings Down the House

★★★★★ Crystal is at his comedic best proving a lifetime of memories are fireproof.

Sign up for new reviews

Copyright © 2026 • New York Stage Review • All Rights Reserved.

Website Built by Digital Culture NYC.