
Can one feel sympathy for sex offenders? That’s a question theatergoers will face as they watch Downstate, a compelling, provocative, and ultimately touching contemporary drama by Bruce Norris, author of Clybourne Park. A stark work of realism, Downstate observes four sex offenders sharing a cramped group home during an especially lousy day in their restricted post-prison existence.
Walking into the Booth Theatre, where Downstate opened on Sunday, the audience will find the curtain raised to disclose the dismal living room of a rundown single-story tract house in suburban Illinois: Grimy pale green walls, frowsy secondhand furnishings, ratty carpet; an accordion-type screen unfolds to reveal a dining alcove used as a bedroom; toilet down the hall, ’70s-era kitchen glimpsed through an entry. Designer Scott Pask’s setting reeks authenticity.
Squabbles over groceries and hogging the bathroom aside, the housemates get along alright, although a vague sense of homophobia hovers within the place like a bad smell. The talkative Gio (Al’Jaleel McGhee) is an amiably aggressive Black dude in his jacked-up 30s. In contrast, close-mouthed Felix (Adrian Martinez) is a morose, middle-aged fellow who mostly hangs out in his room behind that plastic screen. Dee (K. Todd Freeman) is a 50-ish gay showbiz veteran with a sharp eye and sharper tongue. Dee also tends to Fred (Francis Guinan), a partly disabled elderly music teacher with an ingenuous manner who navigates the place in a motorized wheelchair. Specifics regarding everybody’s crimes emerge when gimlet-eyed parole officer Ivy (Liza Colón-Zayas) makes a weekly visit.
[Read Roma Torre’s ★★★★★ review here.]
When Ivy talks with the men, details concerning curfews, tight restrictions on their phone use, travel, and contact with others, as well as problems about food stamps, crummy jobs, bus routes, and hostile neighbors paint a sorry picture of their situation. A hard nut, Ivy is scarcely sympathetic. “Well, ya know what?” she says. “Nobody really wants y’all living anywhere, much less in their neighborhood so maybe ya oughta be thankful ya gotta roof over yer head in the first place.”
As the play opens, Fred patiently endures being awkwardly reviled as a “fundamentally evil person” by Andy (Thomas Sadoski), someone he molested at age twelve some thirty years previously. Recently Andy experienced fresh anxiety over his sexual assault. Encouraged by his Karen-ish wife Em (Cassie Beck), Andy has been going lately to therapy and workshops for his trauma, and his observations tend to sound like so much psychological word salad. Formally confronting Fred this way supposedly is part of the healing process. As the play develops, it becomes obvious Andy weirdly enjoys being a pitiful victim whose recall of the incident may not be so accurate as he claims.
Downstate is a drama composed of an accumulation of many small, telling details of characterization and everyday living. Although the story and its staging pack a violent climax, the darker anguish it depicts is quiet; such as how Felix, as a father, desperately misses the teen daughter he once abused as a child and now is forbidden to contact.
The dialogue usually is quick, terse, frank, at times dryly humorous, especially when uttered with point and precision by the superb acting ensemble directed with typical sensitivity by Joe Mantello. The artists dig deeply into their characters, and the result is they portray these people as naturally as the clothes they wear on their backs. Sadoski’s complex performance as woeful Andy, whose misery slowly simmers into rage, serves to drive the drama, and Freeman’s wry, upright attitude as Dee helps to give the audience perspective, but everyone provides sterling work. Immeasurably supporting the artists, Mantello’s production of the play is meticulously finished in every way, from designer Ann Roth’s character-true clothes to the way Heather Gilbert’s unobtrusive lighting design quietly suggests changes in mood.
Originally produced by Steppenwolf Theatre Company in Chicago in 2018 and then by the National Theatre in London in 2019, Downstate first appeared here at Playwrights Horizons late in 2022 (in a different production with a different director, but with Freeman and Guinan in their present roles). Shame on me for missing the play then. Don’t miss it now. Downstate makes few excuses for its characters’ actions, but offers a sober, compassionate look at several flawed men trying to live amid a suspicious, unfriendly world.
Downstate opened November 15, 2026, at the Booth Theatre and runs through January 10, 2027. Tickets and information: downstateonbroadway.com