
Downstate is the rare play that should come with a warning because I have to believe it will be triggering to some people. That’s not a criticism; rather it’s a measure of its intensity, and a reflection of its inherent ability to cut right to the emotional core of its delicate subject matter. For those reasons, Bruce Norris’s daring play is a consummate work brilliantly presented in an immaculate production featuring some of the finest acting you’re likely to see on a Broadway stage.
It tackles the very difficult topic of child sexual abuse, and it paints a bluntly honest picture of the perpetrators and their victims. By the end of its two hours plus, it is likely to challenge life-long assumptions about these most disturbing of human crimes.
It’s set in a group home – a fittingly impersonal space designed by Scott Pask. The play opens with Andy (Thomas Sadoski), a middle-aged man, uncomfortably reading from a letter he’s written to Fred (Francis Guinan), the man who raped him thirty years earlier (when Andy was just twelve years old). Andy is so scarred by the assault, he wants Fred to understand that the trauma continues to wreck his life.
[Read Michael Sommers’ ★★★★★ review here.]
As Andy grows increasingly hostile, Fred, who’s elderly now and in a wheelchair, doesn’t attempt to defend himself, and instead, tries to reassure Andy that he understands his rage. It’s not the typical image of a convicted sex offender and it’s a jarring scene. Andy, hurling gobs of verbal abuse, makes Fred seem like the sympathetic one. Guinan, reprising his role from the Playwrights Horizons production four years ago, comes off as an innocent, forcing you to alter preconceptions. Norris’s script describes him as “childlike, not unlike Fred Rogers”.
Sadoski seems so consumed by Andy’s suffering – the guilt and the shame – I have to wonder how he can endure the role night after night. It’s a painfully nuanced portrait that will haunt you.
Besides Fred, there are three others living in the group home, each of them convicted of varying degrees of sex crimes. Gio (Al’Jaleel McGhee) is a “Level 1,” meaning he’s at low risk of repeat offense. He’s a loudmouth, lacking impulse control; and even though he’s a few months away from being taken off the sex offender registry, he’s the kind of guy you just know is going to screw up. McGhee, making his Broadway debut, is enormously talented, playing the pain in the ass with a degree of charm that makes you want to root for him despite his overbearing nature.
Felix (Anthony Martinez) is the opposite of Gio, a quiet, mentally challenged introvert with a history of lying. He’s also deeply religious. We meet him through Ivy (Liza Colon-Zayas), his overworked probation officer who’s trying to find out why he broke the rules by going online outside the permissible perimeter. Felix is a pedophile, and as heinous as his acts are, he’s clearly a sick individual. As played by Martinez, he’s a tragic figure not undeserving of compassion.
Colon-Zayas fills the role of the frustrated Ivy with a strong sense of duty and empathy. She’s in a difficult job, discovering the human side of these men, so easily written off as inherently evil.
K. Todd Freeman, returning as Dee from the earlier Off-Broadway production, is once again delivering a bravura performance embodying every aspect of a black man from a broken home who’s both brutal and brutalized. It’s a tribute to his talent that he can utter a laugh-out-loud line and then spark a violent outburst the very next second. Dee, like all the others in the house, was abused as a child. Despite having that in common with Andy who was raised in a white middle-class suburb, the point is made clear – one’s sense of “victimhood” is often determined by class and race.
Joe Mantello, at the helm of this production, proves why he’s the go-to director for deeply sensitive works. He has a gift for defining and expanding the scope of dramas from some of our finest playwrights. His track record is enormously impressive. And here he works his great skills once again with a deft hand, evoking Norris’s narrative with power, restraint and unexpected humor. There’s no need for ambient music, and you won’t find any fancy projections here. Mantello understands the sheer potency of a well-written scene.
Downstate is not an easy play to watch. But it is a stunning achievement, meticulously constructed and emotionally devastating. Norris isn’t out to change minds. Instead he casts an unflinching light on one of society’s darkest scourges, challenging us to confront an unsettling question: What exactly makes a monster?