★★★★☆ Lydia R. Diamond hits one right up the middle with her play about the first female Negro League ballplayer
Julie Madly Deeply: A Drop of Golden Sun
★★★★☆ Sarah-Louise Young’s musical tribute to Julie Andrews is full of heart, enthusiasm, and a totally voluntary singalong
Much Ado About Nothing: A Mostly Giddy Thing
★★★☆☆ We do spy some marks of love in this Shakespeare in the Park production starring Danielle Brooks
Mac Beth: Something Wicked Cool This Way Comes
★★★★☆ Director Erica Schmidt and an all-female cast update Shakespeare’s bloody tragedy for the Instagram age
Enter Laughing The Musical: Let’s Hope You Like Corn
★★★☆☆ The York revives its old-fashioned theater-themed hit in honor of the company’s 50th anniversary
Curse of the Starving Class: A Blessing of a Revival
★★★★☆ Director Terry Kinney finds the perfect brooding poetic despair in Sam Shepard’s late-’70s drama
Tootsie: They’ve Got Big Heels to Fill
★★★★☆ The Sydney Pollack–directed ’80s movie gets a Broadway makeover courtesy of screen-to-stage musical specialist David Yazbek
The Pain of My Belligerence: Love Hurts
★★★☆☆ Halley Feiffer stars in her own play about a writer battling Lyme disease and an obsessive codependent relationship
All My Sons: Arthur Miller’s Still-Shattering Backyard Tragedy
★★★★☆ More than 70 years after its premiere, Arthur Miller’s breakthrough drama proves as powerful (and timely) as ever
Burn This: Keri Russell and Adam Driver Lack Sizzle
★★★☆☆ Keri Russell and Adam Driver play unlikely lovers in the first Broadway revival of Lanford Wilson’s play