
Try to remember your first brush with The Fantasticks. If you’re a lifelong New Yorker, it was probably at the 135-seat Sullivan Street Playhouse (RIP), where it opened in 1960 and ran for 17,162 performances. Or later, farther uptown, at the Jerry Orbach Theater, where a 2006 revival ran for another 4,390 performances. More than likely, it was at a high school or community theater: Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt’s eight-character show was pretty much designed for cash-strapped drama departments; all it requires is a piano, a few carefully chosen props, and an unshakeable belief in storybook romance.
Now, The Fantasticks has arrived on Broadway, courtesy of Second Stage, in a moony production that in many ways matches The Fantasticks in your mind. Same monochromatic set—here, scenic designer Jason Sherwood has created a perfect whitewashed canvas for Jen Schriever’s stunning sunset-hued lighting—just in a bigger venue. Same lush, lyrical songs: the swoony “Soon It’s Gonna Rain”; the tender “They Were You”; the giddy “Metaphor,” both a love duet and a paean to the eponymous part of speech. But now the musicians have expanded to eight (Sam Davis has provided lovely new orchestrations). Director Christopher Gatelli even provides a few thoughtful nods to the original—for instance, replicating the instantly recognizable handwritten logo that was created by Schmidt, a onetime commercial artist.
There is one modification: Matt and Luisa, the two young lovers at the center of our charming fairytale, have become Matt (Maxim Chlumecky, adorable) and Lewis (Nathan Levy, equally adorable). Similarly, the supporting characters of the boys’ sparring but secretly scheming fathers have been transformed into mothers; here, they’re played by Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles, and I challenge you to name two better actresses for these parts. (They nearly walk off with the show with their vaudeville-ready renditions of “Never Say No” and “Plant a Radish”—a brilliant song that rhymes “children” with “bewilderin’” and “progeny” with “hodge-pogenee.”) The roles of the narrator, El Gallo (Zane Phillips, looking very Travis Kelce), the players for hire—The Old Actor (ultimate character actor David Patrick Kelly) and The Man Who Dies (comic dynamo Kevin Del Aguila)—and The Mute (Ahmad Simmons, whose megawatt smile could melt even the hardest of hearts), remain unaltered.
[Read David Finkle’s ★★★☆☆ review here.]
Ideologically, it’s a big change; dramaturgically, it’s surprisingly small. A few words here, a couple pronouns there. Fantasticks fanatics will notice that the repeated “reckless and terribly gay” lyric is missing in Act 2’s “Round and Round.” In the lead-in to Luisa’s “Much More,” her “Don’t let me be normal” plea has become, for Lewis, “Let me be somebody special!” And El Gallo briefly acknowledges the situation: “Two boys? And you’re not worried?” Bessie shrugs it off: “They love each other. Why should we be worried?” Why indeed! “Good point. Very good point,” he replies. Truthfully, the gender swap has been done so seamlessly that a Fantasticks newbie would never know the pair previously had been Matt and Luisa. The structure and soul of the show remain untouched—it’s still a sweet little story about two naive young lovers, their madcap hopes and dreams, and the harsh realities that bring them back to earth.
This reimagined version, which Tom Jones worked on before his death in 2023, isn’t new for Broadway; it premiered in 2022 at Michigan’s Flint Repertory Theater. But putting the production in the Helen Hayes Theater almost guarantees you’ll be seeing Matt and Lewis soon on a stage near you.
The Fantasticks opened November 16, 2026 at the Helen Hayes Theater and runs through February 7, 2027. Tickets and information: 2st.com