• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Reviews from Broadway and Beyond

  • Now Playing
  • Recently Opened
    • Broadway
    • Off-Broadway
    • Beyond
  • Critics’ Picks
  • Our Critics
    • About Us
    • Melissa Rose Bernardo
    • Michael Feingold
    • David Finkle
    • Elysa Gardner
    • Jesse Oxfeld
    • MICHAEL SOMMERS
    • Steven Suskin
    • Frank Scheck
    • Roma Torre
    • Bob Verini
  • Sign Up
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Now Playing
  • Recently Opened
    • Broadway
    • Off-Broadway
    • Beyond
  • Critics’ Picks
  • Our Critics
    • About Us
    • Melissa Rose Bernardo
    • Michael Feingold
    • David Finkle
    • Elysa Gardner
    • Jesse Oxfeld
    • MICHAEL SOMMERS
    • Steven Suskin
    • Frank Scheck
    • Roma Torre
    • Bob Verini
  • Sign Up
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
November 16, 2026 9:59 pm

The Fantasticks: Somehow Short of Fantastic(k)

By David Finkle

★★★☆☆ The Tom Jones-Harvey Schmidt off-Broadway classic in a Broadway revisal, Christopher Gattelli directs, choreographs

Matthew Chlumecky, Nathan Levy in The Fantasticks. Photo: Joan Marcus

In a program note for the Broadway production of The Fantasticks, the late lyricist-bookwriter Tom Jones informs the audience that in a 2021 email from a Flint, Michigan theater runner, he was politely asked to revise his script so that the young lovers were no longer boy and girl but boy and boy. After consideration he decided to accommodate the correspondent and then says he had ’’great fun” doing so.

As part of the result, the Tom Jones-Harvey Schmidt work is now being presented uptown in 2026 with other alterations. For instance, the boys’ parents are no longer their fathers but their mothers.

Yup, this is a new version of The Fantasticks. It’s decidedly not the version that opened in 1960 at The Sullivan Street Playhouse and stayed there until 2002, closing after 17,162 performances.

[Read Melissa Rose Bernardo’s ★★★★☆ review here.]

Nope, this isn’t that phenomenally lucrative Lore Noto production (the original investors received a 240% return on their money), although when first glimpsed the new producers as well as set designer Jason Sherwood want you to think you’re seeing something very close to it. The stage features an oversized replica of The Sullivan Street Playhouse and includes a piece of furniture on which “Sullivan Street Playhouse” is stenciled.

Furthermore and perhaps immediately promising, both a piano and a harp have been placed in plain view. The reference will be instantly recognized by the 1960-2002 patrons. The original musical accompaniment was provided by piano and harp—and only piano and harp. That stringed-instrument duo accounted for a good deal of the musical’s charm.

Uh-oh, hold the cellphone. Here and pretty much as soon as the instruments are seen, they’re taken—yanked?—offstage as if to say, “Enough of charm. Don’t you know this is Broadway, and we’re obliged to offer something grander?” They’re suggesting that in our contemporary political climate charming theater is no longer a commercial commodity.

So here’s what you get in what might more properly be advertised as The Fantasticks II. Let’s begin positively with the Jones and Schmidt factor that can’t be criticized: the score, now delivered by a seven-piece band, playing Sam Davis’ expanded orchestrations.

The team wrote at a time when songwriters were happily committed to make every song land. Among them, the opening, “Try to Remember,” conjures irresistible nostalgia; “Soon It’s Gonna Rain” captures incipient young romance. Barbra Streisand recorded “Soon It’s Gonna Rain.” She also recorded “Much More.” So did Tony Bennett.” Perry Como recorded “Try to Remember” as did Andy Williams, Josh Groban, and on and on.

Granted, those were the imminently fading days when recording artists and their A&R men habitually looked to musicals for new material. The Fantasticks provided a rich place to find it.

But otherwise, what does this revisal offer today’s audiences, elements that likely wouldn’t have gotten by back then? Sure, why not turn the teenage lovers into two young men? In society now, gay couples are regularly left to their devices. The mother of Lewis (Ruthie Ann Miles) is not trying to convince son Lewis (Nathan Levy) that his infatuation must be a passing fancy, nor is the mother of Matthew (Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer) forcing the same outlook on Matt (Maxim Chlumecky).

The drawback here—it’s not meager—is that the boys’ love affair comes across as tepid. At the same time, the friction  between the mothers tends to center around each other’s gardens. As a partisan of the genuine—in my estimation—Fantasticks, I don’t recall any such articulated contretemps. I do recall the camaraderie around “Plant a Radish,” which is wisely retained here and well sung by the adept Miles and Kritzer.

Also, from start to finish the revised book and lyric attributed to Jones does retain, under Christopher Gattelli’s certainly confident direction and choreography, the narrating El Gallo (Zane Phillips, staunch throughout), the funny Old Actor (David Patrick Kelly, always a cast plus), The Man Who Dies (Kevin Del Aguila, another regular reliable), and other amusing characters.

But does this Jones revision maintain the original clarity?  The applicable word is “overdone.” With this renewed gander at The Fantasticks the question continues to be: Can’t audiences be trusted to get the clear point? The auxiliary question continues to be: Must today’s audiences be coddled with the excessive? If the answer to both queries is yes, then more’s the pity.

The Fantasticks opened November 16, 2026 at the Helen Hayes Theater and runs through February 7, 2027. Tickets and information: 2st.com

About David Finkle

David Finkle is a freelance journalist specializing in the arts and politics. He has reviewed theater for several decades, for publications including The Village Voice and Theatermania.com, where for 12 years he was chief drama critic. He is also currently chief drama critic at The Clyde Fitch Report. For an archive of older reviews, go here. Email: david@nystagereview.com.

Primary Sidebar

The Fantasticks: Fresh but Still Familiar

By Melissa Rose Bernardo

★★★★☆ The longest-running musical in history makes its Broadway debut with a new boy-meets-boy story

The 2026 Christmas Spectacular: Ringing in the Holidays with The Rockettes

By Michael Sommers

★★★★☆ Plenty of fancy dancing, Santa, The Nativity and more return to Radio City Music Hall

Downstate: The Disturbing Humanity of the Inhuman

By Roma Torre

★★★★★ Bruce Norris's unsettling drama returns to New York in a captivating Broadway production directed by Joe Mantello

Downstate: Real Life Realism

By Michael Sommers

★★★★★ Joe Mantello stages Bruce Norris’ compelling drama set in a group home for sex offenders

CRITICS' PICKS

We'll See

We’ll See: Sitting Down to Dinner, Once Again, With Our Beloved Apple Family

★★★★★ Our contemporary Chekhov, Richard Nelson, returns with another up-to-the-minute Rhinebeck-set drama

The company of The Heart. Photo: Joan Marcus

The Heart: A Bold New Musical Chronicles a Life-or-Death Story

★★★★☆ Electronic music drives an exceptional musical about a major medical procedure

Imaginary Invalid

The Imaginary Invalid: Just What the Doctor Ordered

★★★★☆ Molière’s final play gets a lively, luxe-looking 90-minute adaptation by its star, Tony winner Bill Irwin

860: Billy Crystal Brings Down the House

★★★★★ Crystal is at his comedic best proving a lifetime of memories are fireproof.

Other Desert Cities

Other Desert Cities: A Piercing Revival of Jon Robin Baitz’s Best Play

★★★★☆ John Benjamin Hickey directs a new Broadway version of the darkly funny family drama

School Girls; Or, The African Mean Girls Play: Jasmine Amy Rogers and Denée Benton Battle It Out

★★★★☆ Whitney White directs a first-rate cast in Jocelyn Bioh’s comedy

Sign up for new reviews

Copyright © 2026 • New York Stage Review • All Rights Reserved.

Website Built by Digital Culture NYC.