
The narrator of Conor McPherson’s The Good Thief, a vortex of a monologue, never gives his name. Nor in the course of 70 info-filled minutes does he spill much to demonstrate that he’s anything along Robin Hood lines. No, he’s not good in the way of stealing from the rich to give to the poor.
Far from it. He sits alone at a table occasionally gulping a glass of beer(?) in a dark room of black-painted stone with a narrow upstage window through which a tepid light falls (Wilson Chin’s set). The window can surely be taken as a metaphor for the supplying of carefully restrained information. The room itself certainly raises the question: Is this a prison cell? At first, it doesn’t seem to be. But later?
What does our central character (Christopher Fitzgerald) have to say in a series of compulsive confessions, occasionally interrupted by Jen Leno’s shadowy lights dimming for a few seconds? (McPherson’s script is divided into chapters, which aren’t entirely followed on stage.)
Who is this voluble fellow addressing the audience directly, eager to talk about himself, eager to talk about himself jovially matter-of-fact? And in the act of doing so can’t be described as anywhere near alienating. It may be he’s so ingratiating that we sitting targets find ourselves trying—and failing—to keep in mind that we’re listening to a shameless criminal presenting his incriminating resumé many times over.
Our unidentified entertainer, recently dumped by girlfriend Greta and not pleased, confides that he’s a hit man, “a paid thug,” ready to do anything—and armed while at it—if the price is right. He more or less boasts that he’s “scared people,” “set fire to places,” “shot people.”
More specifically, he gets around to recalling— reminiscing might be more accurate—about one hit assignment, a team effort that turned sour. He and a few other cohorts were sent to intimidate someone named Mitchell who ran a few warehouses where questionable holdings were sometimes stored.
Off he goes with his marauding band when too soon matters got out of hand. Mitchell is shot in front of his wife and their little girl Niamh. Our thief, endlessly thorough in saving his hide, reckons that his only recourse in the circumstances is to lam it with mother and daughter. All the same, he knows he’ll be tailed by his now erstwhile co-conspirators as well as the law.
The remainder of his compulsive outpouring covers his escapade, escaping one tight situation after another while keeping Mrs. Mitchell and the constantly clinging Niamh out of harm’s way.
He and his charges get away with it. Granted, spilling those crucial plot beans may come across as a spoiler. Then again, if the traveling threesome hadn’t, would he be going along in such a satisfied, even boastful, manner? Yes, enforcement surfaces helpfully, ex-girlfriend Greta reenters to supply additional aid. As an eventual result, this unreformed thief has reason to feel good and does—and there’s McPherson’s title.
Looking somewhat scruffy, Fitzgerald commands the proceedings, as director Justin Wald takes care to avoid even a second’s static sense. His performance is no surprise. For some time now, he’s provided the same completely imposing job whenever, in major or supporting roles, he’s given the spotlight.
There are any number of New York actors—the honorary title the Brits bestow is jobbing actors—who have their distinctive, honed talents, their charms, their inner light and are readily hired to shine as part of an ensemble.
As a result. Fitzgerald has earned nominations for the heavy theater awards passed around every spring. So, it’s a pleasure to have the opportunity of seeing him showcased in such a challenging solo role, seeing him meeting the challenge so comfortably, so assuredly, so effortlessly, so winningly.
The Good Thief opened November 17, 2026, at the Irish Repertory Theatre and runs through December 13. Tickets and information: irishrep.org