
These days, the Winter Garden Theatre sounds suspiciously like a Harry Styles concert. Music blaring and audience members screaming…for Shakespeare. Eight times a week, 1,500 people are paying an average of $200 to see the 427-year-old Much Ado About Nothing.
Unfortunately, we can’t give the Bard all the credit. Much as many of us love him, and Much Ado, the hooting and hollering and sold-out houses are almost certainly due to its above-the-title stars, Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell, longtime members of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. (Keep your eyes peeled for special appearances by Loki and Peggy Carter, their respective MCU alter egos.)
Atwell and Hiddleston may be the draw—and they’re an absolute delight as the bickering Beatrice and Benedick, two self-proclaimed singletons engaged in a long-running battle of wits—but there are abundant pleasures to be found in director Jamie Lloyd’s gloriously giddy pretty-in-hot-pink production. Come for the superheroes, stay for the dance party.
[Read Frank Scheck’s ★★★★☆ review here.]
Armed with a trimmed-down script by Jonathan Glew, Lloyd has packed the show with a host of 1980s–2000s club hits—a playlist on the website would not be unwelcome—by artists including Taylor Dayne, Deee-Lite, and C+C Music Factory, some of which are sung by the divine Mason Alexander Park, all of which are certified bangers. In the very first scene, the Beastie Boys’ “(You Gotta) Fight for Your Right (To Party)” heralds the entrance of Benedick and his bros. Cue the chest-bumping! Let the festivities begin!
Among this band of merry male revelers: the debonair prince, Don Pedro (Gerald Kyd); the dashing young count Claudio (James Phoon); Don Pedro’s surly brother, Don John (Tim Steed); and Don John’s ne’er-do-well follower, Borachio (Mika Onyx Johnson). They’ve all just descended on the Messina estate of Leonato (Forbes Mason), uncle to Beatrice and father to Hero (Mara Huff), whom Claudio quickly spots and falls madly in love with. “Is she not a modest young lady?” Claudio asks, staring at Hero who’s standing, hip popped, looking fierce in a fuzzy lavender belly shirt and matching booty shorts, glittery tights, and knee socks. (You didn’t think you’d escape a Jamie Lloyd production without seeing knee socks, did you?) She’s accessory-maxing with sparkly stacked bracelets, a puffy heart-and-flower beaded cellphone crossbody strap, star-shape barrettes, and rhinestones around her eyes. Naturally, he puts a proposal plan in place immediately.
After a night of impressively synchronized carousing (Fabian Aloise provided the straight-outta-Limelight choreography), Don Pedro and his pals decide to undertake what he calls as a Herculean task: “to bring Signor Benedick and the Lady Beatrice into a mountain of affection the one with the other.”
The prince, Leonato, and the soon-to-be-married Claudio get to work on Benedick, which gives Hiddleston the chance to display his great gift for slapstick, as well as his easy camaraderie with the audience. He seems to address three individual theatergoers here (much to their delight): “One woman is fair, yet I am well. Another is wise, yet I am well. Another virtuous, yet I am well. But till all graces be in one woman, one woman shall not come in my grace.” Then, Hero and her attendant, Margaret (Park), play Cupid with Beatrice. In the first scene, she wouldn’t even think about marrying: “Not till God make men of some other metal than earth!” Now? Beatrice briefly drops her defenses. “Contempt, farewell! And maiden pride, adieu!”
Naturally things go awry post-intermission—pro tip: Before you slut-shame a woman at the altar, get a close look at whoever’s under that fursuit head—but remember, this is a Shakespeare comedy, so happy-ever-after is all but guaranteed. That giant hot-pink heart the size of a Macy’s Thanksgiving Day parade balloon is also a big hint.
The puffy heart, the piles of pink confetti, the house music beats—it might be overwhelming. Of course, for Lloyd fans, it’s almost an exercise in excess, especially on the heels of his and designer Soutra Gilmour’s black-and-white (and occasionally blood-red) Sunset Boulevard, their A Doll’s House that starred Jessica Chastain and a turntable, and their shades-of-gray Betrayal with Hiddleston. Gilmour also designed the dynamite costumes, which include Hero’s ruffled corset wedding dress, Claudio’s metallic leather suit, and Beatrice’s enviable orchid-hued lamé jumpsuit.
So here’s a litmus test: If the thought of Baz Luhrmann’s 1996 manic, MTV-era Romeo + Juliet movie sends you into fits, this is not your Much Ado. No judgment! Some people like their Shakespeare straight-up. But if you like it on the rocks—party people, this is for you.
Much Ado About Nothing opened Nov. 18, 2026, at the Winter Garden and runs through Jan. 10. Tickets and information: muchadobroadway.com