
Seeing Blue Man Group return to a New York City stage feels like getting reacquainted with an old friend. I’d seen it several times during its 33 year run downtown at the Astor Place Theater. When it closed almost two years ago, it felt like the end of an era. Well it’s back…and this time on a much bigger Broadway stage in a Christmas themed version of the original production.
If you ask me, is it any good?, I’d have to say it’s hard to pass judgment on the show because so much of your appreciation will depend on your taste for its peculiar brand of entertainment. It’s an inspired novelty that’s both refreshingly weird and completely non-sensical.
The Blue Men are mysterious, alien-like humanoids who never speak and communicate mostly through subtle facial expressions and furtive gestures. They also happen to be excellent percussionists. If you were a fan when you first saw them downtown, you’ll know just what to expect.
Despite its subtitle – A New Holiday Surprise – there’s really not much to be surprised about in this comeback. All of their familiar stunts are featured. There’s the marshmallow toss in which they catch dozens of marshmallows in their mouths thrown in quick succession from across the stage. And then they graduate to paintballs which they eventually spit out onto canvasses to create live art. The most impressive part of the act involves contraptions made up of dozens of PVC pipes strapped together, which they whack with a mallet, much like a vibraphone. It’s quite a feat as they bang away on the pipes to produce such familiar holiday tunes as Jingle Bells and the Nutcracker theme.
As for what’s new…audiences entering the theater will find a cozy setting (designed by Scott Adam Davis) consisting of a framed house with a roaring fire and giant windows revealing an intense blizzard outside. The show begins in the strangest way as a TV set turns on featuring a 1950’s style black and white program introduced by an announcer welcoming us to “Gimbals Annual Holiday Special.” Why the old-fashioned motif? It’s never really explained even as the announcer continually pops up on the screen with a variety of reports – from a description of modern plumbing complete with a graphic illustration… to advice on how to entertain during the holidays… to commercial breaks advertising appliances and even a made up drug called Relaxative intended to relieve holiday stress. What any of that has to do with the show is hard to say. But maybe when they eventually pull the plug on the TV, it’s meant to re-enforce the holiday spirit. To that end, there’s a Christmas tree with plenty of gifts, some of which are handed out. And there’s lots of audience participation.
Speaking of the audience, whoa to anyone who arrives late. They will be subjected to an embarrassing shout out. Of course it’s all in fun. What makes Blue Man Group such a trip is the sense that anything goes, and much of it feels improvised. It’s messy with paint splattered all over, whether it’s poured onto drums as they pound away or aimed at a volunteer plastered to a giant canvas. At one point they travel up an aisle with a remote camera which they place inside an audience member’s mouth and then project the live image onto a giant screen. Gross! Right? Kids all around us were eating it up. And quite literally too as candy canes were hurled out, along with streamers, confetti and giant rubber balls for the audience to bat about.
At the risk of sounding racist, it’s hard to single out the cast members because all Blue Men look alike. But to be fair, the five listed in the Playbill are Dan Cooper, Wes Day, Mark Frankel, Alexander Pobutsky and Pete Simpson. They’ve all performed as Blue Men for dozens of years and it shows. In addition there are two very talented supporting drummers whom we mostly don’t see. Kaylie Brooke and Anastasiya Kostromina are credited in the program as “The Spirit.”
Blue Man Group artistic director Matt Ramsey helms the 90 minute show with an everything-but-the-kitchen-sink sensibility. It’s stuffed with some inventively wild ideas that don’t always land. But there’s a reason Blue Man Group has lasted all these years. They still have a knack for turning the ridiculous into something ridiculously entertaining.
Blue Man Holiday Surprise opened November 17, 2026, at the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre and runs through January 10, 2027. Tickets and information: blueman.com