
Here is a professional secret: By their very nature, drama critics tend to be unreliable reporters about shows involving illusion and legerdemain because we are trained and accustomed to suspending our disbelief at the drop of a hat (with or without a rabbit in it). When a helicopter materializes onstage in Now You See Me Live, my only reaction is “Wow, that’s magic!” Accordingly, fans of such tricky attractions may wish to consult other expert sources before investing in tickets for Now You See Me Live, which landed at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre on Wednesday for an engagement through the holidays.
Gabriella Lester, James More, Darcy Oake and Matthew Pomeroy are billed as the “Four Horsemen” of illusion on Broadway, although the show offers no storyline at all, nor more than a lip-service nod to the Now You See Me film franchise. Later during the 80-minute doings, the foursome is joined by Eden Choi, billed as a special guest. Dressed in hipster black garb and usually performing their wondrous feats as solo turns, these young, cool-looking artists present a program of various card manipulations, escapes, sleight-of-hand trickery, and well, magic, as when a spectator’s phone appears to get trashed and yet later is removed intact from inside a melon.
A videographer and a big screen onstage provides close-up views (or distractions?) of the artists’ swift appearances, which often involve audience participation. This interaction with civilians lends spontaneity to a show that at times seems oddly mechanical in its expertise. The bright, bespectacled Pomeroy also serves the show as emcee and genially deals with tongue-tied volunteers. The staging is quick, the lighting is surprisingly bright, and usually the music is very loud, even when it’s being suspenseful.
To my romantic taste, the most impressive act was Oake’s old-school tribute to Houdini: The tall, tattooed Oake is suspended with both wrists locked in manacles to a plank and then his head immersed in a padlocked glass box full of water; holding his breath while picking all those locks. Looked pretty death-defying to me. In contrast to the high-energy quartet, Choi functions furiously within a Zen-like aura of calm as he makes small items appear and disappear before finally manifesting a veritable waterfall of playing cards.
Apropos of holiday entertainment, numerous youngsters were in the audience the other evening. Working the crowd, Pomeroy asked a kid named Jasper, “Who is the one person that delivers gifts to people all over the world?” Without a beat, Jasper replied, “Amazon.”
Now You See Me Live opened November 18, 2026, at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre and runs through January 10, 2027. Tickets and information: broadway.nowyouseemelive.com